• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Nonna Faye's Italian Kitchen - Authentic Wood-Fired Pizza & Pasta in Sulphur Springs, TX

Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen in Sulphur Springs, TX, offers an authentic Italian dining experience centered on wood-fired pizzas and hearty pasta dishes. The standout crust is light, airy, and perfectly chewy, complementing fresh, carefully marinated ingredients like oven-roasted mushrooms. Guests rave about the warm, inviting atmosphere and attentive service, making it ideal for gatherings large and small. Signature dishes like the Funky Pig and the spicy Hawaiian pizza showcase bold flavors and quality craftsmanship. With generous family specials and decadent desserts, Nonna Faye’s combines traditional recipes with a vibrant, welcoming vibe that easily makes it a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike.

Nonna Faye's Italian Kitchen at a glance

  • Address 221 Main St, Sulphur Springs, TX 75482, United States
  • Phone +1 903-919-0191
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Nonna Faye's Italian Kitchen: Reviews & Ratings

Bruno Estrada
5

When we came in the restaurant was almost full, but they still made room for our party of nine and the service was AMAZING! The food was outstanding, best pizza we’ve ever had. 10/10 recommend!

Shelly Ahlfinger
5

I have found my pizza spot!! We went in for lunch today and the place smelled amazing!! We were promptly greeted by friendly faces and seated. My husband ordered the pizza rolls and I had the BBQ chicken mushroom pizza. The gentleman preparing the pizzas was amazing!! The crust on my pizza was light and airy with perfect consistency. The mushrooms on my pizza were definitely not from a can. He told me that they are marinated and oven roasted which you can absolutely tell without a doubt. Cooked in a wood fired pizza oven to perfection. My Husband’s pizza rolls, which I hope they NEVER take off the menu were wonderful. We will for sure be regulars. Thank you for the wonderful experience.

Kristi Graves
5

My brother and I had a great meal Tuesday evening. I cannot remember our server's name but she took great care of us: friendly, gave great food recs and kept our drinks filled. Food came out hot n yummy, started with house cheese bread that was nicely cheesy ans crust had some chew to it-we loved the marinara for dipping. We got the Funky Pig she rec'd and the Ranch Hand, both were very tasty with that same great slightly chewy crust. We also got ramch ans spicy ranch-both tasty but i really liked the spicy for my pizza bone dunking! There was a lot leftover! Met the chef/owner, really nice guy. Next time I look forward to trying a pasta as well! Will definitely be back!

Richie at Thunder Media
5

Came in at the last second right before closing… Cali and Chrystine were so kind to still take care of us. Cali, the chef who prepared our pizza, did an excellent job. We ordered the pizza of the month, the spicy Hawaiian and it was so delicious. We also got a couple massive chocolate cookies were excellent! Highly recommend!

Bob Evens
5

I'm so glad our town has this pizza joint. They have great pizza and the pasta is super good. The lunch family special is a great deal. You get an order of bread sticks, 1 large salad, any 2 pizzas, a pasta, and 4 drinks. Currently the price is 50 dollars. The vibe here is also really good. Great service

Rox La Rosa
5

Awesome brick oven smell as soon as you walk in the door! We had a late lunch so we were there by ourselves. Their pizza dough/bread is fantastic! They brought a complimentary basket of bread and we devoured it even though we also ordered their bread with mozzarella. The mozzarella was very fresh and tasted amazing! We shared an Alfredo pasta with sausage and enjoyed every single bite. Very smooth, flavorful sauce and the sausage was just perfect, not oily at all but with extreme flavor. The workers were super friendly and just the perfect combination of interaction and allowing us to enjoy our meal. We are looking for another excuse to return to Sulphur Springs to repeat the experience.

S P Fletcher
5

The kind of place where the food is better than what you can make at home! And that says everything. I enjoyed a pasta dish, local beer on tap, and had awesome service and community connection with all the staff. The outdoor sidewalk seating is smart bonus for lovely weather in Texas and Nonna Faye’s is easy to stroll up to or park right nearby. I tried other places in town and the passion and quality into their food is by far the best at this fun classic menu with woodfired pizza and other Italian cuisine. It’s awesome to watch them make the pizzas and oven baked bread in a huge oven, going full speed! You gotta check it out!

Scott Blankenship
5

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ We hosted our son's rehearsal dinner at Nonna Faye's Pizzeria and couldn't have been happier with the experience! The food was absolutely delicious - the pizza and pasta were amazing, and even the Caesar salad was on point. Everything was fresh and flavorful. The service was outstanding. The staff was attentive and made sure all of our guests were well taken care of throughout the evening. Their attention to detail really made the night special. Highly recommend Nonna Faye's for any celebration or just a great Italian meal. They made our special occasion truly memorable!

Location

  • Nonna Faye's Italian Kitchen
    Nonna Faye's Italian Kitchen
    221 Main St, Sulphur Springs, TX 75482, United States Hotline: +1 903-919-0191

Nestled in the heart of Sulphur Springs, Texas, Nonna Faye's Italian Kitchen offers an authentic slice of Italy right on Main Street. This charming eatery is a testament to traditional Italian flavors, skillfully crafted with fresh, quality ingredients and cooked in a wood-fired pizza oven that elevates every dish.

Walking into Nonna Faye’s feels like stepping into a warm, inviting kitchen where the air is rich with the aroma of roasting mushrooms and freshly baked crusts. The standout here is undoubtedly the pizza—each pie boasts a light, airy crust with just the right amount of chew, a perfect canvas for vibrant toppings. Customers rave about the BBQ chicken mushroom pizza, where marinated, oven-roasted mushrooms add depth and freshness that can’t be matched by canned alternatives. The wood-fired technique infuses the crust and toppings with a smoky, irresistible charm that keeps patrons coming back.

One cannot overlook the culinary artistry behind the pizza rolls, a unique offering that has quickly become a fan favorite. Paired alongside generous portions of house-made cheese bread with a tangy marinara for dipping, every bite unfolds layers of flavor and texture. The “Funky Pig” and the “Ranch Hand” pizzas highlight the kitchen’s creativity and mastery of balancing bold tastes with traditional roots. The inclusion of both ranch and spicy ranch dipping sauces offers a playful contrast, enhancing the overall experience.

Beyond pizza, Nonna Faye’s serves hearty pasta dishes that match the same standard of quality. The lunch family special is a great deal, bringing together breadsticks, salad, pizzas, pasta, and drinks—perfect for groups eager to explore the menu’s diversity. The atmosphere here is relaxed yet lively, paired with attentive, friendly service that makes every visit memorable. Meeting the chef-owner reveals a passion for community and cuisine that infuses every dish.

Whether you’re stopping in last minute or planning a family outing, Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen delivers consistently excellent food with impeccable service. Their monthly specials, like the spicy Hawaiian pizza, and indulgent desserts such as massive chocolate cookies, cap off a meal perfectly. It’s no wonder locals consider this their go-to Italian spot. For lovers of authentic, wood-fired Italian cuisine, Nonna Faye’s is a must-visit destination that masterfully combines flavor, tradition, and hospitality.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards